By Dr. Ali Zalme
All too often we are forced into assumptions and caricatures of a particular
group that fail to expose nuanced experiences of the members of that group. My
new book, Home and Sense of Belonging among Iraqi Kurds in the UK (Lexington
Books, 2020), is an effort to voice out lived experiences of an uncharted
immigrant community – that of Iraqi Kurds in the UK. It looks at their
different generational experiences in the context of transnational family life,
with particular regard to their sense of home and belonging.
The book is also about my own journey searching for identity. As a
Kurd I never belonged to Iraq where we were persecuted, discriminated against
and subject to genocide. And as a Hawrami speaker I have not always been
relaxed about my Kurdishness and have often felt like an outsider –a minority
within a minority. This book is an attempt to understand a complex diaspora in
which many people find it difficult to belong. Among the voices of individuals
from Iraqi Kurdish communities here in the UK my voice is also present.
As an interpreter and community organiser working closely with
Kurdish families and individuals in Bristol and other major cities, I have long
considered questions about home and belonging. One project I was involved in was
establishing a Kurdish supplementary school or so-called Sunday school to help
Kurdish children learn their mother tongue. That particular experience and my
contacts with Kurdish families led to my master’s dissertation on cultural
identities among diasporic communities. In particular, I was interested in ideas
about the physical home in the UK and the imagined ancestral home among the
Kurdish second-generation in Bristol (Zalme 2011). I
continued to work and extend my research with the Kurdish community during my
PhD, on which this book is based.
As a first-generation Kurd in Britain I am interested in the
differences and similarities between parents and children, and between me (as a
male researcher) and my female participants, in our understandings of home and
belonging. In addition to my gender and generational identity, my linguistic background
as a Hawrami speaker was highly relevant to my fieldwork. Being Hawrami and having
grown up in an environment in Iraqi Kurdistan where Kurdish-Sorani speakers
were dominant (and this is still the case in the diaspora) has often made me
question who I am and where I belong.
In the diaspora I have tended to involve myself in many activities
to support the Hawrami, which was not always possible in Kurdistan. There the
hegemonic nationalist ideology situated all Kurds as a unified people regardless
of the ‘trivial’ narratives relating to ethnic, religious and linguistic
minorities. In Britain, this disjuncture between my lived experience of being
born and raised a Hawrami and the culture of others in the UK Kurdish community
has remained acute. In examining my own sense of home and belonging and that of
my participants, this book pays close attention to the diversity of the Kurdish
diaspora and introduces the notion of a diaspora within a diaspora. By concentrating
on Iraqi Kurds, it shows how identities formed back home in Iraqi Kurdistan have
had a significant impact on the community in the UK.
This book challenges the prevalent essentialist and nationalist
approach to research of diasporic communities. Instead of providing
generalisations about whether the younger generation will follow their parents
or take a different route, my findings suggest a more complex picture about the
degree of parental power and political interest. The life stories of different
members of Kurdish immigrant families show that they are each negotiating the
making of new homes on a daily basis. A great number of my participants have
suggested that most members of diasporic communities are family orientated and tend
to establish a new home in the UK while erasing the other due to these family
commitments.
My research has also shown that Kurdish women have more opportunity
to be independent in exile than those living in Kurdistan, and yet they
maintain their ethnic identity and have strong affiliations with the Kurdish
question (that is, the nationalist project of the nation-building process). New
challenges and new opportunities face Kurdish women here as they find
themselves living between two contrasting cultures. As a result, their concept
of ‘home’ is highly complex: many
vividly express their frustration regarding the patriarchal culture at home in
Iraq, but at the same time they struggle to integrate into a British society
that gives them greater independence. Instead, they live in an imaginary home
that is neither quite here nor there but somewhere in-between. My book concludes that we need to be more
focused on the particularity of Kurdish cases and avoid homogenisation with
respect to Kurdish diaspora studies in the United Kingdom.